Year | Player | Club |
1933 | Keith Dunn | Sturt |
1991 | Mark Naley | South Adelaide |
2006 | Brett Backwell | Glenelg |
2021 | Bryce Gibbs | South Adelaide |
NB In 1983, Stephen Kernahan polled the most Magarey votes but was ineligible due to suspension.
Year | Player | Club |
1933 | Keith Dunn | Sturt |
1991 | Mark Naley | South Adelaide |
2006 | Brett Backwell | Glenelg |
2021 | Bryce Gibbs | South Adelaide |